From Lost to Listed: Powerful Scripts and Checklists for Contacting Expired Listings

Introduction

When a real estate listing expires, it often leaves both the homeowner and the previous agent frustrated and disappointed. For a proactive agent, however, expired listings represent a valuable opportunity to step in, build trust, and help these sellers achieve their original goal: successfully selling their property. But approaching expired listings requires tact, strategy, and the right set of tools.

In this guide, we’ll cover essential scripts and checklists to help you reconnect with these potential clients. With the right approach, you can effectively turn an expired listing into a new business opportunity and give homeowners a fresh perspective on selling.

1. Understanding Expired Listings and Why They Matter

Before diving into scripts and checklists, it’s crucial to understand why listings expire in the first place. Common reasons include:

  • Incorrect Pricing: If the home was priced too high, it may have discouraged potential buyers from showing interest.

  • Poor Marketing Strategy: Limited or ineffective marketing can lead to low visibility, resulting in minimal inquiries or viewings.

  • Staging or Presentation Issues: A poorly staged home may not connect with buyers on an emotional level, leaving them uninterested.

  • Market Conditions: Sometimes, listings expire due to factors beyond the agent’s control, such as market downturns or seasonal fluctuations.

Expired listings matter because they signal to the agent that the homeowner is likely motivated to sell but just needs the right guidance. By addressing their concerns and offering a tailored plan, you can provide a fresh start and win their business.

2. Preparing to Contact Expired Listings: Your Pre-Call Checklist

Reaching out to homeowners with expired listings requires thorough preparation. Here’s a checklist to ensure you’re ready:

  • Research the Property: Familiarize yourself with the home, its features, and previous listing details. Knowing specifics allows you to speak with confidence and show that you’re prepared.

  • Identify Market Comparables: Understanding the current market can help you address pricing issues. Prepare data on similar properties in the area that have sold recently to guide the homeowner.

  • Analyze the Listing Photos and Description: Assess the quality of previous photos and descriptions. If these were subpar, it provides a tangible area for improvement.

  • Review Past Marketing Efforts: If possible, analyze how the property was marketed. Did it lack social media exposure, professional photos, or open houses? These insights allow you to suggest more effective marketing strategies.

  • Prepare Your Unique Value Proposition (UVP): Be ready to explain how your approach will differ from the previous agent’s. Highlight your successes with similar properties and outline your marketing expertise.

3. Effective Scripts for Contacting Expired Listings

Using the right script can make all the difference. Here are a few scripts tailored to specific situations, allowing you to open the conversation with professionalism and empathy.

Script 1: Initial Phone Contact

This script is ideal for a first call to a homeowner with an expired listing. Your goal is to establish rapport and set up an in-person meeting.

Hi [Homeowner’s Name], this is [Your Name] from [Your Real Estate Agency]. I noticed that your listing for [Address] recently expired, and I wanted to reach out to see if there’s anything I can do to help you achieve your goal of selling your home. I specialize in helping homeowners who’ve had difficulty selling their properties, and I’d love to meet to discuss some fresh strategies that might work better for you.

Could we set up a time to chat in person? I’d like to share some specific ideas on how to improve your property’s market appeal and reach the right buyers.

Script 2: Addressing Common Objections

If the homeowner seems hesitant or reluctant, they may be wary due to their past experience. This script addresses common concerns about re-listing.

[Homeowner’s Name], I completely understand your frustration with the process, and I can see why you might be hesitant. However, I believe there are a few specific adjustments we can make that could significantly increase your chances of selling this time. For example, I have access to [describe unique marketing tools, professional networks, or marketing tactics].

Would you be open to a quick meeting to discuss these options? Even if you decide not to move forward with me, I’d be happy to provide some advice at no obligation.

Script 3: Follow-Up Message for Voicemail or Email

If you can’t reach the homeowner by phone, leave a voicemail or send a polite follow-up email.

Hi [Homeowner’s Name], this is [Your Name] from [Your Agency]. I noticed that your listing at [Address] expired recently, and I wanted to extend an offer to help. Many of my clients came to me after previous listings expired, and with a few strategic adjustments, we were able to get their homes sold. I’d be happy to discuss how we can take a different approach for your property. Please feel free to reach out to me at your convenience. Thank you, and I look forward to connecting soon.

4. Key Points to Cover in Your First Meeting

Once you secure a meeting, it’s crucial to cover specific topics to build trust and demonstrate your expertise. Use this checklist to guide the conversation:

  • Review of Property History: Start by asking the homeowner about their experience with the previous listing and any challenges they faced. Listening actively shows empathy and helps you identify pain points.

  • Pricing Strategy Discussion: If pricing was a factor in the listing’s failure, discuss recent market comparables and a realistic pricing plan. Highlight how correct pricing can drive more buyer interest.

  • Marketing Plan Outline: Showcase your marketing strategy, including online listings, social media outreach, virtual tours, and professional photography. Explain how your approach differs from the previous listing’s efforts.

  • Staging and Presentation Advice: Offer suggestions for improving the home’s presentation. For example, discuss staging, landscaping, or simple interior updates that can make the property more appealing.

  • Addressing Timing Concerns: Reassure the homeowner that the timing might be better now than when they previously listed, depending on current market trends. Providing market data can support this point.

5. Follow-Up Checklist: Keeping the Conversation Alive

Not all homeowners will make a decision immediately. Following up consistently is key to staying top-of-mind and demonstrating your commitment. Here’s a simple follow-up checklist:

  • Send a Thank-You Note: After the initial meeting, send a personalized thank-you note, either by email or regular mail. Express gratitude for their time and reinforce your desire to help them succeed.

  • Provide Market Updates: If they haven’t decided yet, periodically share market updates or recent sales in their area. This positions you as a knowledgeable resource and shows that you’re invested in their success.

  • Share Success Stories: Occasionally share brief success stories of similar expired listings you’ve turned into successful sales. Keep these messages concise and relevant to their situation.

  • Stay Connected on Social Media: If they’re comfortable, connect on social media and occasionally interact with their posts. This gentle reminder of your presence can reinforce your relationship.

Conclusion

Turning expired listings into opportunities requires a combination of empathy, persistence, and a well-organized approach. By using these scripts and checklists, you can approach expired listings with confidence, address homeowner concerns, and showcase your unique value as a real estate professional. With the right techniques, you can transform these once-lost opportunities into successful transactions, helping homeowners achieve their goals while growing your business.